Shared Tables: How Chinese Food Became a Jewish American Tradition

On a snow-bright December 25th in cities and suburbs across the United States, Chinese restaurants bubble with life as families and friends gather. There is laughter, steam rising in clouds from platters of lo mein, and the familiar crinkle of fortune cookies. It’s a scene replayed across generations, so iconic that it transcends cliché: on Christmas, America’s Jews eat Chinese food. This is more than a quirky custom — it’s a powerful testament to cultural resilience, connection, and the evolving American palate.

Roots in Proximity, Barriers, and Acceptance

The alliance between Jewish and Chinese foodways traces to the Lower East Side of Manhattan at the dawn of the 20th century. At a time when much of immigrant New York maintained cultural enclaves — Italians ate at Italian restaurants, Germans at German ones, Jews at kosher delis — Chinese restaurants distinguished themselves by welcoming outsiders, Jews included. Many other eateries were laced with signs or symbols of Christianity or simply did not welcome Jewish patrons. The Chinese, fellow “outsiders,” were notably free of such barriers.​

Food: Both Foreign and Familiar

While dishes like sweet and sour chicken, egg rolls, and lo mein presented an escape from the culinary strictures of home, Chinese food also offered unexpected familiarity. Knishes found a cousin in dumplings; scallion pancakes echoed latkes; and crucially, Chinese cuisine traditionally avoided mixing dairy and meat — a kosher principle — even if pork and shellfish were present. Pork, when finely minced or shrouded in a wonton wrapper, became what many affectionately called “safe treyf”: a non-kosher treat that, because it was hidden, felt like a gentle rebellion rather than a transgression.​

Assimilation, Rebellion, and Cosmopolitan Cool

Eating Chinese food became, for many second- and third-generation Jewish Americans, an act of modest rebellion and a badge of modernity. For children and grandchildren of Yiddish-speaking immigrants, a night out at a Chinese restaurant was a way to display worldliness and leave behind the “parochial” tastes and rules of the old country. Chop suey houses and neon-lit chow mein palaces became settings for birthday parties, singles’ events, even Shabbat dinners — a cosmopolitan pursuit that was, ironically, deeply rooted in Jewish immigrant experience.​

Open on Christmas: From Outsider Status to Ritual

The tradition crystallized around Christmas, when the majority of restaurants, businesses, and entertainment venues shuttered for the Christian holiday. For Jews, whose memories included the dangers of Christmas in Eastern Europe — when staying home was sometimes a matter of safety — American Christmas felt isolating. Chinese restaurants’ open doors became a sanctuary, a place to gather with family and celebrate in their own way.​

The earliest record of Jews eating Chinese food on Christmas dates to 1935, when a New Jersey restaurateur delivered chow mein to the Jewish Children’s Home in Newark. Over time, the tradition was immortalized in comedy routines, novels, art, and even Supreme Court confirmation hearings, where Elena Kagan’s quip about eating Chinese food on Christmas was met with knowing laughter.​

Community, Art, and Fusion

The shared story of Jewish and Chinese communities shaped more than menus. On New York’s Lower East Side, art installations — like those of Stephanie H. Shih — celebrate this cross-pollination, showing how pastrami egg rolls and Catskills-style roast pork sandwiches blended culinary histories. Restaurants like the now-legendary Bernstein-on-Essex served kosher egg foo young and drew signs with men in yarmulkes, advertising “the tastiest delicatessen in the world”.​

As Jews moved from the city to the suburbs, Chinese restaurants followed, cementing their place in the landscape of American Jewish life. Some venues — Chai Peking in Atlanta, Genghis Cohen in Los Angeles — leaned into their Jewish clientele with chutzpah and charm.​

Changing Times: New Traditions, Lasting Bonds

Younger generations may now opt for Indian, Thai, or pan-Asian fare, and the pristine nostalgia for Chinese takeout fades somewhat as food culture diversifies. Yet the bond endures — a living tradition, less about food than about hope, hospitality, community, and the search for belonging.​

The story of American Chinese food — especially as it intersects with Jewish experience — is about more than what’s on the plate. It’s about migration and adaptation, about forging friendships across boundaries, and about finding joy and kinship where you least expect it: across a table filled with chopsticks, challah, and the communal language of food.​

Tradition!

Humbly submitted for your consumption,

—Mee Magnum  (“Chop!  Chop!”)

P.S.  This is part two of a two-part series.  To read part one, “The Americanization of Chinese Food: How a Culinary Tradition Was Transformed“, click here.

Please share this article if you enjoyed it!