Share this on...
Long Island’s Fading Fortunes: A Tribute to the Classic Chinese Quest
The Quest to find the best Chinese restaurants on Long Island often leads us down paths paved with nostalgia, but lately, those paths have ended in heartbreak. We mourn the loss of two foundational institutions of Americanized Chinese cuisine: Jade King in Roslyn Heights and Hoi Ming in West Sayville. Though separated by geography, both shared a similar, vital role: serving as beloved, reliable community hubs that ultimately succumbed to time, economics, or retirement.
Jade King: Silenced by Greed in Roslyn Heights
In Roslyn Heights, a tale recently unfolded with sorrow, marking the closure of Jade King, a landmark that offered decades of service. This closing hits particularly hard because the cause was external: the service was silenced, all because a landlord’s greed has grown due to rising costs.
Located at 376 Willis Avenue, Jade King was a local treasure with a casual, friendly air. It had served the community well for over 45 years. It was more than just walls and a sign; it was a home for many, where the community would dine. Neighbors—the fine citizens of this North Shore Gold Coast town—were frequently out in force, filling almost all the tables. The atmosphere was defined by the warmth of gathering with friends and the familiar scent of General Tso’s, offering that crispy, savory bite.
However, The Chinese Quest’s review noted that the experience was mixed. While the establishment must have been doing something right for their neighbors, the specific dishes selected—including Spare Ribs, House Wonton Soup, Lobster Cantonese, Eggplant with Sauteed Chicken, Orange Beef, and Chicken Chow Mein—resulted in a blander selection of dishes. One reviewer called the meal a “Major disappointment,” though they noted the pleasant banter from John, our waiter, whose service to many leads to greatness.
Now, the space, once vibrant, filled with life and culinary art, stands vacant, leaving sadness in each heart. Though a new chain is reportedly coming to take the spot, they can’t replace the history. Jade King’s legacy remains, and it will live in memory, shining ever bright.
Hoi Ming: The Time Warp Retreats in West Sayville
Journeying further East to 469 Montauk Highway in West Sayville, we find Hoi Ming, a restaurant that represented a total immersion into the past. If you are older than 40, entering Hoi Ming was like stepping back into the Chinese restaurant of your youth. You were immediately transported to the early 1970’s.
The visual details were critical to the charm: the old bar, the waiters dressed in white shirts and black ties, and the sight of nearly every table filled (often with Caucasians). The experience was pure Americanized Chinese Food. This included the expected sight of chow mein noodles on every table, small dishes of soy sauce and mustard, and entrees served in those metal serving dishes. The menu even featured the classic structure broken into Column A and Column B. The crowds proved their enduring local popularity, with EVERY parking spot taken even on a Monday night.
The dining experience at Hoi Ming, however, was as much a trip back in time as the décor. While the BBQ Spareribs were loved and the Wonton soup was enjoyed, the Hot and Sour Soup was reported to be SWEET. Furthermore, the review noted that the meats (pork, chicken, or beef) were very dry, leading the reviewer to wonder if they were from the same era as the décor. The Kung Pao Chicken lacked “KUNG” or “POW,” and the Orange Beef lacked spice or bite. Despite the food issues, the service was great throughout the evening, featuring a funny waiter named Philip.
Before its closure, the recommendation from The Chinese Quest was emphatic: Do NOT change a thing. The establishment was urged to preserve it for eternity as a national historic landmark.
Sadly, Hoi Ming closed early in 2020 when the owners retired. The building was subsequently remodeled, with all traces of the old place removed and covered in bland white vinyl siding, suggesting that the charm and time warp feel are now gone.
A Shared Fate
Jade King and Hoi Ming, though closed for different reasons (economic pressure versus retirement), illustrate the precarious position of the classic, local Chinese restaurant. Both were deeply established and well-attended by their communities—Hoi Ming had a full parking lot on a Monday night, and Jade King consistently drew the fine citizens of Roslyn Heights. They specialized in the comfortable, Americanized menu that shaped the culinary roots of many.
As Mee Magnum reflected after Hoi Ming closed, he loved the restaurant for its ambiance, noting he felt like he was in heaven the moment he walked in, despite some bland dishes. Both restaurants offered that unique blend of comforting dishes and engaging service (like John at Jade King or Philip at Hoi Ming) that made them truly local institutions.
The closing of these Kings and Mings serves as a bittersweet reminder that the “Good Old Days” may or may not have been so Golden after all, but their memory, like a delicious Mai Tai garnished with a shriveled maraschino cherry, is something we will surely miss.
Submitted by Tailwind.